| Date | Results | |
| May 5, 1996 | Catawba Indians 4, High Point Panthers 3 | |
| April 18, 1996 | High Point Panthers 7, Coker Cobras 0 | |
| April 15, 1996 | High Point Panthers 6, Queens Royals 1 | |
| April 11, 1996 | High Point Panthers 4, Pfeiffer Falcons 3 | |
| April 3, 1996 | High Point Panthers 6, St. Andrews Knights 1 | |
| April 2, 1996 | High Point Panthers 5, Lees-McRae Bobcats 2 | |
| March 30, 1996 | High Point Panthers 6, Erskine Flying Fleet 1 | |
| March 29, 1996 | High Point Panthers 7, Longwood Lancers 0 | |
| March 27, 1996 | High Point Panthers 6, Barton Bulldogs 1 | |
| March 26, 1996 | High Point Panthers 5, Belmont Abbey Crusaders 2 | |
| March 21, 1996 | High Point Panthers 7, Mt. Olive Trojans 0 | |
| March 12, 1996 | High Point Panthers 4, Catawba Indians 3 | |
| Feb. 28, 1996 | High Point Panthers 7, Guilford Quakers 0 | |
| Feb. 26, 1996 | Elon Phoenix 7, High Point Panthers 0 | |
| Feb. 23, 1996 | High Point Panthers 5, Wingate Bulldogs 2 | |
| Feb. 19. 1996 | High Point Panthers 6, Gardner-Webb Runnin' Bulldogs 1 | |
| Oct. 10, 1995 | High Point Panthers 6, Catawba Indians 1 | |
| Oct. 3, 1995 | High Point Panthers 5, Methodist Monarchs 2 | |
| Sept. 19, 1995 | High Point Panthers 5, Wingate Bulldogs 2 | |
| Sept. 8-10, 1995 | Sept. 8-10, 1995-Tournament -- | |